The High Court of Justice has issued a sweeping ruling invalidating a legislative amendment intended to prevent enforcement and arrests of young Haredi individuals who fail to report for military service. The decision was reached unanimously by a nine-judge panel led by Deputy President, Justice Noam Sohlberg. The legal basis for the revocation rests on two primary grounds: a procedural flaw in the legislative process and a substantive defect concerning the law's constitutionality.
Justice Sohlberg, who authored the lead opinion, noted that the law as enacted deviated from the original subject matter of the bill as introduced during its first reading. According to the High Court’s ruling, this constitutes a foundational flaw, as the law was passed without the proper and orderly legislative procedure required. Beyond the procedural issue, eight of the nine judges ruled that the law does not meet the requirements of the Limitation Clause due to its severe infringement on the right to equality.
The verdict emphasized that the state is obligated to enforce criminal law equitably and that creating a mechanism exempting an entire population group from enforcement is not considered a legitimate objective. The Court clarified that the law deprived the IDF of a central enforcement tool for addressing non-compliance without providing an alternative mechanism, thereby exacerbating existing inequality in the burden of service. In his opinion, Justice Sohlberg clarified that enforcement against the Haredi population stems from evasion of service rather than the act of Torah study itself.
In response to the decision, Knesset Member Meir Porush of United Torah Judaism harshly criticized the ruling, describing it as a campaign of persecution against the Haredi public and the world of Torah. For legal observers, this judgment marks the limits of the legislature’s ability to make changes during legislative processes without adhering to standards of proper procedure, and clarifies the High Court’s position regarding the state's discretion on issues of equality in military service.
Practically, this means the immunity of evaders from arrest, as sought by the amendment, is null and void, returning enforcement powers to security authorities in accordance with the original Defense Service Law.