In a dramatic ruling issued on September 8, 2026, the High Court of Justice unanimously overturned the government's decision to appoint Yifat Ben-Chai Segev, attorney Kinneret Barashi, and Dr. Chaim Schein as members of the Second Authority for Television and Radio Council. The decision follows five petitions filed by various bodies, including the Movement for Quality Government and the Journalists' Organization, which challenged the appointments.
At the core of the petitions were allegations regarding harsh and vulgar public statements made by the candidates against media outlets under the Council's supervision, raising concerns about impartiality. The Attorney General supported parts of the petitioners' arguments, noting that the factual basis presented to the appointments committee was incomplete and failed to address concerns regarding conflicts of interest or hostility from the candidates.
Supreme Court President Isaac Amit emphasized in his opinion that the committee has a duty to base its decisions on a solid factual foundation. He stated that repeated public statements by a candidate against the entities they are intended to oversee are highly relevant to assessing their fitness for public office. Regarding Dr. Ben-Chai Segev's appointment as chair, Justice Amit ruled that the Prime Minister breached his conflict of interest agreement, as Ben-Chai Segev testified in his criminal trial. The court rejected the argument that her completed testimony negated the conflict, as the arrangement is intended to prevent even the appearance of favoritism toward witnesses after their service concludes. The court further invalidated a later government decision, noting it was not an independent or full review of the facts.
Due to these administrative failures, the court ordered the committee to re-examine the appointments. Justice Ruth Ronen concurred with the President, while Justice Alex Stein dissented regarding the scope of the re-examination, noting no principled objection to re-selecting the candidates, provided proper conflict-of-interest arrangements are implemented. The judgment underscores the importance of proper appointment procedures and the government's duty to provide full factual disclosure to review bodies.