The High Court of Justice has recently addressed the issue of using technological tools for tracking voters during election day. This follows the issuance of an order nisi in petitions filed against the Central Elections Committee’s (CEC) decision to authorize parties to provide real-time updates on citizens who have voted or who have not yet reached polling stations. Under the order, the CEC is required to present its position and explain why the decision allowing this activity should not be revoked, with a hearing scheduled for the coming days.
The case reached the court following previous developments, including a decision by the CEC Chairman, Judge Noam Sohlberg, which was subsequently overturned by the full committee panel. Judge Sohlberg's initial decision, which sought to limit the use of dedicated apps for managing election day, faced sharp political criticism. Following a High Court hearing, the matter was returned to the CEC, where it was decided by majority vote to reverse the original ruling and permit the continued use of the 'Elector' app for voter monitoring purposes.
During the High Court hearing, representatives of the Likud party, represented by Adv. Ilan Bombach, argued that changing the procedure so close to the election causes significant damage to the party's field operations. Conversely, the justices raised questions regarding the nature of these arguments and the alleged discrimination between parties based on seniority and access to databases. Justice Khaled Kabub questioned whether the criteria for permitting such activity should depend on technological capability or a party's historical data.
Adv. Bombach clarified that the party's complex organizational structure relies on these tools over time. The CEC is required to submit its formal response to the court by the set deadline, ahead of a decisive hearing to be held within a few days. The issue raises significant legal and public questions regarding the balance between a party's need to mobilize voters and the right to privacy, as well as concerns regarding the use of personal data on election day. The upcoming legal discussion is expected to clarify the limitations placed on parties on election day and impact how electoral campaigns manage direct communication with voters in real-time.