The Supreme Court has issued a principled and significant ruling regarding political party conduct on election day, establishing that transferring the names of citizens who have arrived at polling stations to exercise their right to vote constitutes a violation of privacy. The decision was reached by a panel including Justices Yael Willner, Alex Stein, and Khaled Kabub, with Justice Willner authoring the lead opinion. The Court has effectively ended a long-standing practice in which party representatives inside polling stations provided real-time updates to party headquarters regarding the identities of those who voted, often utilizing election management software such as "Elector."
In the ruling, the justices noted that no legal source of authority exists allowing party representatives to transmit this type of information. The Court emphasized that in the absence of clear, explicit, and detailed statutory authorization, long-standing practices cannot serve as a source of legitimacy. The justices held that the act of going to a polling station, or refraining from doing so, represents a value-based decision; therefore, data regarding the exercise of the franchise is defined as sensitive information, as it reflects the citizen's views and worldviews. Consequently, the practice is contrary to the Privacy Protection Law.
This decision follows previous proceedings where the Central Elections Committee, which includes numerous coalition members, previously rejected Justice Noam Sohlberg’s decision to halt the use of such reporting systems on election day. During legal arguments, representatives of certain parties expressed fierce opposition to the ban. For example, attorney Ilan Bombach, representing the Likud party, argued that prohibiting this practice severely impairs the party's ability to manage election day, as it is a central operational tool. Conversely, the justices clarified that the protection of privacy outweighs party customs in this case.
This ruling carries significant, widespread implications for the conduct of election campaigns in Israel, setting a new standard for voter privacy protection and requiring parties to align their operational methods strictly with the written legal framework, while ceasing the tracking of citizens' actions on election day.