The High Court of Justice ruled on Wednesday that the issue of political parties using the 'Elector' app for election campaigns must be returned to the Central Election Committee for further deliberation. The decision follows a petition filed by the Likud party against a previous ruling by the Committee Chairman, Justice Noam Sohlberg, which prohibited the app on grounds of infringing upon citizen privacy and violating the law.
The panel of judges, comprising Yael Willner, Alex Stein, and Khaled Kabub, accepted Likud's argument that the Committee Chairman lacked the exclusive authority to issue such a ruling, noting that this power rests with the committee in its entirety. The judges underscored a significant concern regarding the procedural authority. During the hearing, the court expressed surprise that the State Attorney's Office presented conflicting positions from the Attorney General and the Committee Chair on one side, and the Central Election Committee on the other.
Following a proposal by the court, Justice Sohlberg agreed to refer the matter back to the committee, with a hearing expected this coming Sunday. Likud’s counsel, Adv. Ilan Bombach, argued that the ban during the height of the election period inflicts significant damage on the party due to its heavy investment in the database. Conversely, Justice Willner clarified during the proceedings that there is a basis for the argument that reporting on citizens who do not vote constitutes an infringement on privacy and voter autonomy.
The implications of this decision may be significant, as the Central Election Committee currently holds a coalition majority, potentially leading to the reversal of Sohlberg’s original decision. Nevertheless, any new decision by the committee remains susceptible to a further petition to the High Court, which would shift the focus from procedural questions of authority to substantive questions regarding the legality of real-time voter tracking.