During a hearing held on Monday, the Supreme Court bench deliberated on the petition filed by the family of the late Yuval Castleman against the State Attorney's Office decision not to open a criminal investigation into the officers who managed the scene where he was killed. Castleman, who neutralized terrorists in a November 2023 Jerusalem attack, was shot to death by reservist soldier Aviad Freija after discarding his weapon and raising his hands. The family alleges that police conduct at the scene suggested an obstruction of justice, claiming that relevant officials possessed exculpatory footage early on but failed to examine the evidence and rushed to release Castleman's body for burial.
According to the family, this failure necessitated complex legal and public efforts to exhume the body for an autopsy. During the hearing, Supreme Court Justice David Mintz spoke harshly regarding the police's conduct at the scene. The justice characterized the behavior as unprofessional, using the term 'criminal negligence' in relation to the officers' actions. However, despite the unusual tone and sharp criticism, Justice Mintz clarified that from the legal standpoint required for High Court intervention, there is no gap sufficient to justify changing the prosecution's decision to close the case.
Consequently, the court suggested the family consider withdrawing the petition, and the family chose to consult before reaching a final decision. It should be noted that alongside these proceedings, a separate criminal process is underway against Aviad Freija, who is charged with manslaughter with diminished responsibility for Castleman's death. The emerging ruling reflects the legal principle that the court avoids interfering with the discretion of law enforcement authorities in criminal cases, even when severe factual criticism of their conduct arises.
For the public, the case underscores the complexities of judicial review regarding prosecutorial case closures, particularly in instances involving national sensitivity and allegations of significant police failures.