The Central District Court in Lod heard appeals this week from Maxim Barbraman and Omri David Peretz, two friends of the deceased, Eldar Dayan, who are suspected of committing his murder. As reported by Walla, Judge Michal Barak-Nevo decided to deny the appeals and keep both men in custody until August 24. This decision comes amidst ongoing intensive investigative efforts in the case, which have yet to conclude.
The court noted that while there are various questions regarding the sequence of events, the evidence collected thus far establishes a substantial suspicion against the suspects. The ruling followed proceedings in the Magistrate's Court, where it was revealed that even after 24 days in custody, a final pathological report determining the exact cause of Dayan's death has yet to be submitted. Furthermore, it emerged that at this stage, no direct forensic evidence links Barbraman or Peretz to the murder itself.
The defense argued that there is no justification for continued detention, noting among other things that police simultaneously arrested five other individuals involved in a fight with the deceased prior to his disappearance. However, Judge Barak-Nevo clarified that there is no requirement for suspicion against suspects to strengthen or increase at every detention hearing. It was further determined that the existing suspicion does not rely solely on them being the last individuals to see Dayan alive.
The police investigation is currently proceeding along two tracks: the investigation into the friends suspected of murder, and an investigation into those involved in the altercation that preceded the incident. The police are examining whether there is a connection between the injuries Dayan sustained in that fight and his death, although the latter five individuals are not currently accused of murder. State representatives clarified in court that these are complementary rather than contradictory lines of inquiry.
Another point of contention involves the suspects' versions of events versus security camera findings, with police claiming discrepancies regarding the locations where they parted ways with the deceased. Conversely, the defense emphasizes that the suspects cooperated and identified the relevant location even before their arrest. Another issue raised concerns the examination of Peretz's mobile phone, where suspected deletion of content is being investigated—a claim his attorney rejects while highlighting his client's cooperation. As of now, the question of the circumstances of death remains open, and the continued detention is intended to allow for the completion of investigative actions.