Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara submitted her position to the High Court of Justice this Wednesday regarding petitions calling for a state commission of inquiry into the October 7 events and the 'Swords of Iron' war. At the outset, Baharav-Miara clarified that, in principle, a state commission of inquiry is the most distinct and appropriate legal instrument for examining extraordinary events, owing to its professional independence and lack of political affiliation.
However, the Attorney General noted a substantive difficulty stemming from the significant time elapsed since the war began, which she cited as approximately two years and ten months. She stated that the lack of a government decision regarding the format and timing of the inquiry creates a significant problem, carrying a real risk of impairing the investigation's future effectiveness and leading to cumulative evidentiary damage.
Despite this principle-based view, Baharav-Miara indicated that given that Israel is in the midst of elections for the 26th Knesset, and considering the standards of restraint that apply to an outgoing government exercising its authority, she believes it would be correct to allow the incoming government to address and decide on the matter. The Attorney General’s position follows a previous status update from the government, which argued that legislative processes on the subject were not completed due to time constraints, and that the matter lies at the heart of a political dispute in which the court should not intervene at this stage. The government added that the court should exercise restraint given the political sensitivity of the period.
Following the publication of this stance, sharp criticism was voiced by non-parliamentary bodies. The Movement for Quality Government attacked the proposal for a delay, arguing that it is impossible to acknowledge the necessity of a commission for truth-seeking while simultaneously suggesting it wait for a new government—a process that could take many months. According to the movement, the ongoing delay hinders the investigation into the accountability for the state’s worst failure. The 'October Council' also stated that the Attorney General’s position raises grave concerns regarding the potential for loss of evidence, noting that the time passed since the disaster necessitates urgent action rather than further delay. As of now, the issue remains pending before the High Court, with the gaps between the government's position, the Attorney General's stance, and the petitioners' demands remaining unresolved.