In a significant legal development, Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara filed her detailed response on Thursday to petitions against the Communications Law initiated by Minister Shlomo Karhi. In her filing to the High Court of Justice, the Attorney General stated that the law raises grave questions and represents a severe, irreversible blow to Israel's free media market. She argued that this is an extreme case justifying urgent judicial intervention via an interim injunction to freeze the law's application until a final ruling is reached.
According to her position, the legislative process in the Knesset plenum was flawed and conducted in a distorted manner, containing prominent substantive defects. Baharav-Miara emphasized that the arrangements established by the law lack sufficient safeguards to protect the principles of freedom of speech and the press. She contends that the law's implementation would effectively abolish the central mechanism intended to ensure the independence and reliability of news broadcasts, without providing an adequate alternative to guarantee broadcast quality and its separation from foreign political or business interests.
These developments follow an order issued last July by Supreme Court Justice Ofer Grosskopf, who granted a temporary injunction delaying the entry into force of specific provisions of the law, which was passed in its second and third readings near the time of the Knesset's dissolution. At that time, the Justice noted that the consolidated petitions raised substantial concerns regarding both the law's legislative process and its substantive content. The Court expressed concern that such far-reaching changes to the media market, particularly during the sensitive pre-election period, could create a new reality that would be difficult to reverse.
Controversial changes addressed in the legal debate include authorizing HOT and yes to own news channels, and the elimination of the structural separation between broadcasting bodies and news companies. Another clause that drew criticism was the removal of the mandatory news production investment requirement, which previously stood at over 50 million NIS for Channel 14. The Attorney General concludes that the petitions have a high probability of success and that the status quo must be maintained to prevent irreversible damage to the media market and Israeli democracy. The matter now rests with the High Court panel to decide on the motion for a permanent interim injunction.