The Public Defender’s Office recently filed an urgent request with the Tel Aviv District Court seeking an injunction against the Israel Prison Service (IPS) following the publication of video footage from a detention facility. In the video circulated in the media and on social networks, Agam Zarfi, who is charged with the murder of Binyahu Rezi, is shown being transferred to the Abu Kabir facility accompanied by masked, armed guards. The video included a caption stating that the detainee is receiving treatment similar to that of terrorists. According to reports, the footage was released only a day after Zarfi filed an official petition against her prison conditions. In its filing, the Public Defender’s Office argued that this constitutes a blatant violation of the Privacy Protection Law and a severe infringement on the right to a fair trial, emphasizing that the detainee remains innocent until proven guilty as her trial is ongoing. The office added that the display of the detainee's personal belongings, including hygiene products, constitutes degrading and unjustifiable treatment.
Conversely, Minister of National Security Itamar Ben-Gvir defended the measures taken by the IPS. The Minister clarified that current policy is intended to enforce order and discipline even against criminal offenders, and he sharply attacked the position of the Public Defender’s Office. Ben-Gvir claimed that the detainee's conduct within the prison justified the transfer to another facility and the actions taken against her, while accusing the Public Defender’s Office of double standards regarding different cases. In the public discourse that followed, the Public Defender’s Office emphasized that using prison corridors as a film set violates the professional standards expected of a state body like the IPS. In response, Minister Ben-Gvir stressed that he would not allow detainees to run prisons or disrespect the guards. As of now, no official response has been received from the IPS spokesperson regarding the claims raised in the petition. The central legal issue at the heart of the request is the boundary between security and disciplinary authority within detention facilities and the right to privacy and human dignity of a detainee who has not yet been convicted. The court will be required to rule on the legality of the publication and the use of this footage within the framework of the filed petition, with both sides remaining divided over the significance of the actions taken in the field.