According to a report by Channel 13, a legal crisis has emerged between Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana and the Knesset's legal department regarding compliance with a High Court of Justice (HCJ) ruling. The core of the dispute lies in the requirement to hold new elections for the position of State Comptroller, a move ordered by a five-justice panel of the Supreme Court, headed by President Yitzhak Amit. The report states that the court unanimously ruled the previous elections for this position void and ordered a re-vote.
Knesset Legal Advisor, Adv. Sagit Afik, holds the position that the legislative branch must respect the ruling of the supreme judicial authority and act to hold elections in accordance with the law. Conversely, Speaker Ohana opposes the advisor's position and is unwilling to implement the ruling's results, refusing to move forward with new elections. Due to this professional and principled gap, it is reported that Ohana is seeking private legal representation for the case, rather than the standard representation provided by the Knesset's legal department.
The petition in question was filed by a citizen named Yaron Gadot. In the original ruling, sharp criticism was directed at the conduct of the Knesset Speaker. Deputy President, Justice Noam Sohlberg, noted that Ohana’s directive to Knesset members regarding the possibility of documenting their votes constitutes a violation of Basic Law provisions and could render them a dead letter. Furthermore, previous Channel 13 reports indicated that private political consultations took place in which senior coalition members expressed opposition to holding the new elections. It was also reported that Justice Minister Yariv Levin expressed opposition to complying with the ruling in this case.
The request for private representation is considered an unusual step in the parliamentary landscape, as the legislative branch is generally represented in court by its own legal counsel, who is entrusted with defending the rule of law and the position of the Knesset as a state institution. The Knesset Speaker's refusal to use the services of Adv. Afik reflects deep tension between the elected echelon and the legal counsel regarding the powers of judicial review over internal parliamentary procedures. For now, the issue before the court concerns not only the question of the State Comptroller elections but also the broader issue of the obligation to obey court rulings and the ability of public figures to separate from state representation in favor of private representation against their official actions.