Central Election Committee Chairman, Justice Noam Sohlberg, recently ruled on petitions filed against a campaign video by the Religious Zionism party that utilized Artificial Intelligence (AI) to depict senior figures in the law enforcement and judicial system. As reported by Maariv, two separate petitions were filed against the video: one by the Israel Bar Association and another by the 'Yashar' party, led by Gadi Eisenkot. The petitioners' arguments focused on two main legal fronts. The Israel Bar Association argued that the video violated campaign regulations by threatening law enforcement officials, thereby harming the proper conduct of the election process. Conversely, the 'Yashar' party claimed that the mere use of public servants' images for political campaigning constitutes a violation of the prohibition against using public assets for political promotion.
In his decision, Justice Sohlberg rejected the petitions based on a legal analysis of the relevant sections. Regarding the claim of intimidation, the Justice noted that it is doubtful whether the officials depicted feel genuinely threatened by the video, and that in any case, the applicability of the legal provision in these circumstances is not clear. Regarding the use of individuals' images, the judge ruled that depicting a public servant for the purpose of criticizing them does not violate the law prohibiting the use of public assets for election purposes.
Justice Sohlberg did not refrain from expressing his personal distaste for the content, describing the viewing experience as difficult given the figures involved and the bitter nature of the content. However, he emphasized that his role as Chairman of the Election Committee requires a decision based solely on legal standards, rather than personal feelings. In conclusion, the Justice stated that where no clear legal grounds have been proven, the law dictates that criticism of such content should be left to the voter's discretion, maintaining a separation between criminal and election law and free political discourse.
The video in question was produced as part of a broad campaign by the Religious Zionism party, led by Minister Bezalel Smotrich, which presents a comprehensive plan for structural changes to the judicial system. The plan, spearheaded by Constitution Committee Chairman MK Simcha Rothman, includes proposals to change the method of appointing judges, limit the powers of the High Court of Justice, and reform government legal counsel, with the party setting their advancement as a condition for its participation in a future coalition.