6 October 2026ynet – RSS חדשות בסינון משפטי

Failed Attempt to Arrest Deserter in Modiin: Violent Clashes

An attempt by the Military Police to arrest a deserter in Modiin led to a mass riot by ultra-Orthodox individuals who breached the building, forcing forces to retreat without making the arrest. The event highlights the friction between the IDF and the police regarding responsibility for enforcing conscription in civilian areas.

Source transparency

This is an original newsroom summary and analysis. The source was not reproduced, and readers can inspect the original publication.

Original publication at ynet – RSS חדשות בסינון משפטי

Why it matters

The incident illustrates the operational and legal difficulty of the security establishment in enforcing the High Court's ruling on ultra-Orthodox conscription, highlighting the deadlock between the military and the police regarding law enforcement responsibility.

Key points

  • ▪A failed arrest attempt in Modiin led to a security force retreat due to mass riots.
  • ▪The ultra-Orthodox 'Black Paint' center mobilizes protesters to prevent arrests.
  • ▪A professional dispute exists between the IDF and the police over responsibility for enforcing draft orders in civilian spaces.
  • ▪Most current arrests of deserters occur at Ben Gurion Airport, not as proactive urban operations.
  • ▪The incident sparked sharp public criticism from politicians regarding the erosion of the state's ability to enforce the law.

An attempt by the Military Police to execute a proactive arrest of a military deserter in Modiin ended in failure, after a crowd of ultra-Orthodox individuals rioted in the building where the deserter resided, forcing the forces to withdraw. The riots, which took place overnight, were documented on social media, showing protesters infiltrating the residential apartment and clashing with officers. Upon the forces' departure without completing the mission, the deserter was seen heading to the street, where he was greeted with a 'hero’s welcome' on the roof of a car.

According to reports, the mob was summoned to the site by a center known as 'Black Paint,' operated by the Jerusalem Faction, aimed at assisting draft evaders in avoiding arrest. This activity includes distributing a phone number in ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods, through which protesters are summoned to arrest sites to prevent execution. The Israel Police Spokesperson's Unit stated that large forces operated at the scene to extract the soldiers and restore public order.

Conversely, the 'Black Paint' center boasted that thanks to public support, the police left the deserter's home. This incident joins a series of tensions regarding the enforcement of mandatory conscription. Despite a High Court ruling mandating equitable enforcement, the IDF claims that proactive arrests are limited due to a lack of cooperation from the police, without whom operations cannot be conducted in civilian spaces. In contrast, the Israel Police rejects these allegations, emphasizing that this is a mission under the sole responsibility of the Military Police.

At this time, the majority of those arrested for draft evasion are ultra-Orthodox individuals detained at Ben Gurion Airport or border crossings while returning from abroad, rather than through proactive enforcement activities within cities. Public criticism of the case has intensified, with public figures across the political spectrum criticizing the inability to enforce the law, comparing the nature of the activity in some cases to combat zones and calling to end the existence of a 'state within a state.

' As part of the response to enforcement, thousands of ultra-Orthodox recently held street marches against the army, using harsh expressions and publicly demonstrating support for deserters, including the distribution of financial aid to draft evaders.

General information only. This item is not legal advice and does not replace review of the original source.

Back to all legal news

LawFirms.pro

Update or Remove Public Information

LawFirms.pro allows lawyers and the public to submit requests to update, correct, or remove public information for manual review.

Update or Remove Profile