As the 27th Knesset elections approach, various parties are presenting their positions on proposed changes to the judicial system, a topic that has sparked significant controversy in recent years. Many parties have sought to clarify their plans regarding judicial reform, the composition of the Judicial Selection Committee, the powers of the Supreme Court, and the override clause, signaling this issue as the starting point for expected post-October 27 political discourse. The Likud party declined to respond to inquiries on the matter.
The "Yashar!" party, led by Gadi Eizenkot, emphasized its commitment to strengthening democracy and fortifying its foundations, while acknowledging the fragility of the governmental structure in the absence of agreed-upon rules of play between branches of government. The party plans to repeal the law regarding the politicization of the Judicial Selection Committee and lead a professional process aimed at achieving broad consensus, while adopting a constitutional mechanism for judicial selection that protects judicial independence. Furthermore, "Yashar!" opposes the override mechanism and calls for restoring the balance between the Knesset and the judiciary, as well as enshrining a revised mechanism for judicial review of legislation.
The "B'Yachad" party seeks to regulate the relationship between the Knesset, the government, and the court, and to enact a Basic Law: Legislation, which would define the rules for court intervention. The party also plans to enact the Declaration of Independence as a Basic Law, repeal the new law on judicial selection, and prevent the politicization of the system. "Yisrael Beiteinu" is promoting a comprehensive move to establish a constitution for Israel, to be brought to the public for a referendum. The proposed outline, formulated with Prof. Daniel Friedmann, Prof. Uriel Reichman, and Moshe Nissim, will regulate democratic rules of play, fundamental rights, and the balance between branches. The party opposes unilateral amendments and proposes a complete constitutional arrangement that would require a majority of 80 Knesset members to amend.
"Otzma Yehudit" is in the midst of staff work to write a detailed legal platform, which will be presented soon. The "Democrats" party argues that the necessary changes to the judicial system focus on improving service to the citizen rather than destroying democracy. They seek to work toward the establishment of an appellate court, strengthening mediation and arbitration proceedings, expanding staff positions, shortening proceedings, and appointing judges. The party calls for a holistic change in the Israeli system, including the entrenchment of the separation of powers, their independence, and their authorities.
The "Amcha Yisrael" party believes the court has seized excessive powers and proposes an amendment that will allow the will of the people to be expressed through their representatives. The party proposes adding another instance for judicial appointments in a balanced manner, removing Israel Bar Association representatives from the Judicial Selection Committee, and limiting the reasonableness standard. "The Reservists - Economic" party supports changes to the judicial system, particularly in the Basic Law: Legislation, to strengthen the standing of the Knesset. The party proposes a balanced composition for the Judicial Selection Committee and demands a qualified majority of more than 72 Knesset members to override High Court rulings. Regarding the reasonableness standard, the party seeks to narrow it but not abolish it, as part of a comprehensive reform.
"Religious Zionism-Identity" is promoting a continuation of the judicial revolution, including the appointment of a Supreme Court President by secret ballot of judges, splitting the role of the Attorney General, and an override clause as a coalition threshold condition. The Attorney General and legal advisors in ministries would serve as political appointees of the government. The "Zehut" party (running a separate campaign) demands a radical change that restores the judicial system to its original role, suggesting that the public elect Supreme Court judges directly, without a Judicial Selection Committee.
The Joint List supports any step to strengthen the democratic space and protect rights, calling for a balance between branches, especially in a country where the rights of the national minority are harmed. The party demands a balanced mechanism for the Judicial Selection Committee to maintain the system's independence. Ra'am, which previously expressed opposition to major government moves in 2023, declined to comment on its current stance. However, the party has previously expressed the need for checks and balances and called for preventing the concentration of absolute power in one body. Ra'am did not oppose, in principle, a change to the Judicial Selection Committee and even proposed a model that would include representation for the opposition and Arab society.
Shas, whose criticism of the judicial system has intensified, intends to amend the system and restore power to the people and their representatives, in light of rulings they claim harm the Haredi public. "Neither the High Court nor the Attorney General will be able to stop the legacy of the Maran [Rabbi Ovadia Yosef]," they stated. United Torah Judaism, whose votes for judicial legislation were primarily as a coalition obligation, intends to consider changes to the judicial system in light of rulings perceived as harming the Haredi public, and sees a need to change the scope of judges' powers. The "Blue and White" party believes the power of the judicial system is too great and unregulated, yet argues one must avoid the politicization of legal decisions. The party's plan is intended to regulate Basic Laws, limit the court's intervention in government decisions, improve service to the citizen, strengthen oversight of the State Attorney's Office, and regulate the relationship and balances between the branches, while strengthening the Knesset's ability to oversee the government.