The Jerusalem District Court recently ruled on an appeal filed by the 'Darkey Darchei Noam - Beit Shemesh' association and its acting director, affirming the sentences imposed by the lower court. The decision follows a persistent violation of a 2010 judicial demolition order and subsequent unauthorized construction. According to a report by ICE, the legal proceedings, managed by the Department for the Guidance of Prosecutors in the State Attorney's Office following enforcement actions by the National Enforcement Authority for Planning and Construction, confirmed that illegal building activities covering hundreds of square meters were used for schools and kindergartens.
The appellants argued that classroom shortages and the social need for educational activities justified a lighter sentence, but the court rejected this claim entirely. The verdict clarified that public or educational activities do not grant an exemption from the law or justify self-help. Furthermore, arguments regarding selective enforcement and potential future regularization of the construction were dismissed. The court noted that while imprisonment is not customary for a first-time violation of a order, the severity of the circumstances—including years of ignoring a judicial order alongside new illegal construction—necessitates strict measures.
Consequently, the two-month suspended prison sentence to be served as community service for the director remains in effect, along with a three-month conditional sentence, a 50,000 NIS fine, and a corresponding financial commitment. The association itself was fined 200,000 NIS and signed a similar financial commitment. Beyond criminal penalties, judicial orders requiring the structures to be brought into compliance, including potential demolition and a ban on continued use, remain in force.
The National Enforcement Authority for Planning and Construction stated that the ruling sends a clear message that violating a judicial order is not merely a technical matter. According to the Authority, the personal responsibility of directors of associations and public institutions requires them to ensure compliance with legal provisions and court orders, as a worthy goal does not provide immunity from planning and building laws.