The Netanya Magistrate's Court has adjudicated a complex tort claim filed by a man who sustained a severe neck injury during a bachelor party in June 2019 at a hospitality complex. According to the PsakDin report, the incident occurred when the plaintiff, then 34, dived into a swimming pool shortly after arriving. Due to the dive into water only 1. 5 meters deep, he struck his head on the bottom, necessitating complex neck fusion surgery. The plaintiff, represented by attorney Gil Klopstock, argued that the operators of the complex and their insurer, The Phoenix, were negligent for failing to post adequate warning signs.
The claim stated that no signage was present to clarify water depth or prohibit head-first diving, creating an unreasonable risk for guests. Conversely, the defendants, represented by attorney Amichai Truzman, emphasized the plaintiff's conduct, arguing that as a tall individual, he acted recklessly by diving into a raised pool without verifying depth. Judge Noam Raff upheld the plaintiff's position regarding the duty of care owed by business owners, ruling that the failure to post clear warnings constituted negligence.
However, the judge assigned 40% contributory negligence to the plaintiff for his lack of caution. The court assessed the total damages at approximately NIS 454,000, and after the deduction, the defendants were ordered to pay roughly NIS 272,000. Additionally, the defendants were ordered to cover legal fees of about NIS 64,000 plus court costs and expert expenses. This verdict underscores the judiciary's emphasis on the duty of recreation facility operators to provide warning signage, while acknowledging the personal responsibility of individuals using such facilities.
The case serves as a reminder that even when operator negligence is established, the court does not absolve the victim of responsibility if their conduct falls short of the expected duty of care.