The Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court has issued a ruling in a defamation lawsuit filed by Shikma Bressler against Ester Yochai, following a series of posts shared on social media and WhatsApp groups after the October 7 attack. In his verdict, Judge Guy Porer ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff 40,953 ILS in damages, plus 10,000 ILS in legal costs. The court further ordered Yochai to remove the defamatory posts within 14 days.
The lawsuit was prompted by grave allegations against Bressler, including claims that she had prior knowledge of the attack, consented to it, and aided Hamas. This included an edited photo depicting Bressler in a prisoner's uniform under the heading 'Guilty: Treason against the Homeland.' Bressler had initially sought 400,000 ILS in damages, arguing that the posts asserted false facts rather than constituting legitimate criticism. Conversely, Yochai maintained that the publications were political expressions protected within the framework of public discourse.
In his legal analysis, the judge examined how a 'reasonable person' would interpret the content. Judge Porer distinguished between expressions classified as metaphors or opinions within a dispute and factual assertions. For instance, the phrase 'Shikma Bressler's terrorist organization' was not deemed defamatory in a criminal sense. However, claims regarding assistance to Hamas or possession of prior knowledge of the 'impending massacre' were classified as factual assertions. Yochai attempted to base her defense on the 'truth of the publication' doctrine, but the judge ruled that her claims were not supported by evidence and lacked coherent explanation during proceedings. Although the judge noted that Yochai appeared to sincerely believe the content of her posts, he ruled that subjective belief does not provide a defense against defamation when there is no factual basis for the allegations. Given the limited distribution and lack of evidence regarding malicious intent, it was decided not to impose double damages.