A legal case brought before the Petah Tikva Magistrate's Court highlights complex issues surrounding personal injury claims by elderly workers and the liability of business owners for site hazards. At the center of the case is a 74-year-old courier who worked for a law firm. While delivering materials to a printing house, he tripped over a partially secured wooden board, lost his balance, and fell. He was evacuated by ambulance to Ichilov Hospital, where he was diagnosed with a fractured humerus and a head injury.
The National Insurance Institute (NII) recognized the incident as a work-related accident, and the courier received approximately 140,000 NIS in benefits. Attorney Lital Biber-Chaikin of the Biber-Lakua-Chaikin-Harari firm, representing the courier, demanded compensation from the printing house and its third-party liability insurer. The insurer rejected the claim, arguing that the fall was due to the courier's pre-existing instability rather than a safety hazard, citing the employer's claims of past falls and ambulance reports describing a 'technical fall.
' Attorney Biber-Chaikin argued these claims were absurd, noting that someone with chronic instability would likely not be employed in a high-mobility role. She further suggested that an ongoing labor dispute between the courier and his employer may explain the lack of cooperation and absence of photographic evidence from the scene. Following the insurer's refusal, a lawsuit was filed. Ultimately, the parties reached a court-sanctioned settlement where the insurer agreed to pay an additional 60,000 NIS without admitting liability, bringing the total compensation to 200,000 NIS. Attorney Biber-Chaikin explained that in such claims, NII payments are deducted from the final court settlement to prevent double recovery.